In a lengthy opinion authored by Justice Stephen Breyer, and drawing heavily on historical practice of Presidents and the Senate, the United States Supreme Court has upheld the decision of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit in Noel Canning v. NLRB, concluding that President Obama’s three recess appointments to the National Labor Relations Board in January 2012 (Sharon Block, Richard Griffin, and Terence Flynn) were invalid. The Court upheld the right of the President to make recess appointments both inter- and intra-session, but held that it is the Senate that decides when it is in session by retaining the power to conduct business pursuant to its own rules. The Court also found that a recess of less than ten days “is presumptively too short” to permit the President to make a recess appointment, except in “unusual circumstances”, such as a “national catastrophe”. (The recess here was three days.) The Court also decided that the recess appointment power applies to appointments that first come into existence during a recess and to those that initially occur before a recess but continue to exist during a recess.

As a result of the decision, over 1,000 Board decisions likely are now invalid. According to the National Right to Work Foundation, 999 unpublished decisions and 719 published decisions (totaling 1,718) could be affected. The Chamber of Commerce estimates 1,302 decisions from August 27, 2011 through July 17, 2013 to be suspect.

The post U.S. Supreme Court Upholds D.C. Circuit Decision in Noel Canning appeared first on The National Law Forum.