The U.S. State Department and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services announced that they have issued all legally available visas in the unreserved EB-5 Immigrant Investor Program categories for Fiscal Year 2024. Embassies and consulates have been directed to not issue immigrant visas in these categories until the new fiscal year (FY 2025) starts on Oct. 1, 2024.
As discussed in our recent blog post on EB-5 filing strategies, a total of approximately 140,000 immigrant visas are available every fiscal year for employment-based immigrant visas, including the EB-1, EB-2, EB-3, EB-4, and EB-5 categories. Of the 140,000 immigrant visas available annually, the government allocates approximately 10,000 to the EB-5 investor visa program. The visas are also subject to per-country visa quotas. The Immigration and Nationality Act sets the annual limit for EB-5 visas at 7.1% of the worldwide employment limit, of which 68% is available for unreserved visa categories (C5, T5, I5, R5, RU, NU). Additionally, the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 makes unused EB-5 reserved visas from FY 2022 available in the EB-5 unreserved categories for FY 2024.
Among the multiple executive actions the White House announced on June 18, 2024, was one stating it was taking steps to facilitate the process for certain Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) recipients to obtain work visas/status. DACA was created in 2012 by President Barack Obama as a means for immigrant youth who met certain eligibility requirements to qualify for work authorizations and obtain “deferred action.”
While DACA protection has enabled hundreds of thousands of individuals to legally work and live in the U.S., the program has faced considerable uncertainty since 2017, when the Trump administration initially sought to terminate the program, but was prevented from doing so in the federal courts.
The program continues to face legal challenges, and additional litigation before the U.S. Supreme Court is likely. Fundamentally, DACA is not a legal status – the reliance on “deferred action” simply reflects the U.S. Department of Homeland Security’s (DHS) decision not to bring immigration removal proceedings against a specific individual. While many DACA recipients and their employers have since sought to transition to a work visa or other legal status that Congress specifically established in the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), the process for doing so is uncertain, expensive and cumbersome.
Since DACA recipients either entered without authorization or were out of status when they received DACA protection, they are typically ineligible for a transition to a lawful status within the U.S.
Instead, they are required under immigration law to “consular process” outside the U.S. and obtain a work visa at a U.S. consulate. The individual’s departure from the U.S. could trigger removal bars (similar to those described above), requiring the individual to obtain a temporary waiver of inadmissibility from the government. These waivers, known as “d3 waivers” based on the section of the INA to which they relate, can take months to obtain and the outcome of such a waiver is not certain. These cumulative issues have chilled the interest of many employers and DACA recipients in pursuing these waivers.
On July 15, 2024, the U.S. Department of State made changes to the Foreign Affairs Manual (FAM), which is controlling guidance for consular officers at U.S. Consulates on factors to consider when adjudicating waiver requests. The three primary changes that the DOS made to 9 FAM 305.4-3 are:
Expanding the factors that would have a positive effect on U.S. public interests in granting a waiver to include circumstances “where the applicant has graduated with a degree from an institution of higher education in the United States, or has earned credentials to engage in skilled labor in the United States, and is seeking to travel to the United States to commence or continue employment with a U.S. employer in a field related to the education that the applicant attained in the United States….” These changes noted in bold are clearly designed to benefit many DACA recipients.
The second change creates a mechanism for a waiver applicant whose request is denied by a consular officer to request State Department review in circumstances involving “significant public interest,” which in turn cross-references the factors above that are of particular benefit to DACA recipients.
The FAM was also updated to reflect the ability of DACA recipients who have graduated from an educational program in the United States or are seeking to reenter the U.S. with a visa as beneficiaries of an offer of employment to request an expedite of the waiver request. This change is particularly critical as one of the greatest challenges that DACA recipients face when seeking a waiver is the uncertain adjudication period, which often stretches for months.
Collectively, these updates are significant and will benefit several DACA recipients who are beneficiaries of employer sponsorship. These pathways also create a mechanism for U.S. employers to transition DACA recipients from DACA, with its increasing uncertainty, to a more stable work visa. DACA recipients should, of course, plan prudently if considering a departure from the U.S. to apply for such a waiver and should also apply for advance parole before departing the U.S. so as to provide a mechanism for reentering the U.S. if the waiver request is denied.
The filing fee is $580. Fee waiver requests for Form I-131F will not be accepted.
If granted parole, these noncitizen spouses and noncitizen stepchildren of U.S. citizens, if otherwise eligible, could apply for lawful permanent residence without leaving the country.
Additional Information: In its announcement, the agency stated, “Too often, noncitizen spouses of U.S. citizens — many of them mothers and fathers — live with uncertainty due to undue barriers in our immigration system. This process to keep U.S. families together will remove these undue barriers for those who would otherwise qualify to live and work lawfully in the U.S., while also creating greater efficiencies in the immigration system, conducting effective screening and vetting, and focusing on noncitizens who contribute to and have longstanding connections within American communities across the country.”
More information about the process can be found here.
Today, USCIS announced it has reached a sufficient number of registrations for the second H-1B lottery for fiscal year 2025 and has notified all prospective H-1B petitioners with selected registrations that they are eligible to file.
Key Points:
Only petitioners with selected registrations may file H-1B cap-subject petitions for FY 2025, and only for the beneficiary named in the applicable selected registration notice.
A second selection for the master’s cap was not conducted because enough master’s cap registrations had already been selected and sufficient petitions were received.
Registration selection only pertains to eligibility to file an H-1B cap-subject petition. Petitioners filing H-1B cap-subject petitions must still establish eligibility for petition approval based on existing statutory and regulatory requirements.
Additional Information: An H-1B cap-subject petition must be properly filed at the correct filing location or online at my.uscis.gov and within the filing period indicated on the relevant selection notice. The period for filing the H-1B cap-subject petition will be at least 90 days. Petitioners must include a copy of the applicable selection notice with the FY 2025 H-1B cap-subject petition.
USCIS published a final rule that increased fees required for most immigration applications and petitions on Jan. 31, 2024. The new fees are effective as of April 1, 2024, and petitions with incorrect fees will be rejected. Also, as of April 1, 2024, only the new edition of Form I-129, Petition for a Nonimmigrant Worker, will be accepted.
The increased filing fee for Form I-907, Request for Premium Processing Service, is effective as of Feb. 26, 2024. I-907 forms postmarked on or after Feb. 26, 2024, with the incorrect fee will be rejected and fees returned.
To improve immigration processes and provide additional support to immigrants, the Biden administration has announced several policy changes.
Starting Aug. 19, 2024, unauthorized spouses and children of U.S. citizens who have been in the United States for at least 10 years can apply for parole in place, allowing these individuals to obtain green cards without having to leave the country. If approved, eligible family members will have three years to apply for permanent residency while being granted work authorization. By enabling family members to adjust their immigration status from within the United States, rather than traveling abroad and potentially facing a 10-year reentry ban, this change may significantly simplify the permanent residency process for eligible individuals.
The U.S. Department of State has also revised its guidance to favor immigrants with U.S. college degrees and job offers. The updated guidelines clarify that it is in the public interest for these individuals, including those with work authorization from the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, to utilize their degrees in the United States. Consular officers will now have the discretion to weigh an applicant’s college degree and job offer favorably when deciding whether to grant a waiver to a visa applicant who would otherwise be ineligible. These adjustments aim to expedite the work visa process for college graduates.
Additionally, the Biden administration announced plans to double the locations for the Executive Office Immigration Review (EOIR), a program that provides volunteer attorneys in immigration courts for those without legal representation. Currently operating in San Francisco, Chicago, and New Orleans, the EOIR will expand to Maryland, New York City, and Atlanta by the end of the fiscal year. This expansion seeks to ensure fair representation for immigrants during legal proceedings. The EOIR has issued a call for attorneys to provide pro bono support to the program.
To expand opportunities for Latino communities, the Biden administration also announced that the U.S. Department of Education will propose to expand federal outreach programs targeting beneficiaries of the DACA program. Known as the Trio Program, this initiative aims to assist individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds as they transition from high school to college. The Department of Education’s proposal would extend the Trio Program to reach an additional 50,000 individuals.
According to the recent publication of the Spring 2024 regulatory agenda, the Biden administration has the H-1B modernization rule, adjustment of status proposal and seasonal/temporary worker regulations targeted for publication by the end of 2024. The next step toward Schedule A reform will occur this August.
H-1B modernization: The Department of Homeland Security proposed to amend regulations governing H-1B specialty occupations and certain F-1 students. DHS accepted comments on its wide-ranging proposed rule until Dec. 22, 2023 and finalized and implemented H-1B registration selection provisions in April 2024. The agency says it “continues to consider the suggestions made in public comments received as they relate to the other proposed provisions discussed in the Oct. 23, 2023 NPRM, and intends to finalize the remaining provisions in one or more actions.”
Lawful permanent residence (adjustment of status proposal): To reduce processing times, improve agency partnerships and promote efficiencies in visa availability, DHS plans to amend regulations governing adjustment of status to lawful permanent residence in the U.S. including permitting concurrent filing of a visa petition and the application for AOS for the employment-based fourth preference category. The target date for publishing the proposal is now August 2024. After publication, there will be a public comment period.
Schedule A: The Department of Labor is considering updating Schedule A and opened a Request for Information period on Dec. 21, 2023 that was extended through May 13, 2024. During this period, the public provided input on whether Schedule A served as an effective tool for addressing current labor shortages, and how DOL can create a timely, coherent, and transparent methodology for identifying science, technology, engineering and mathematics and other occupations that are experiencing labor shortages while ensuring the employment of foreign nationals does not displace U.S. workers or adversely affect their wages and working conditions. According to the regulatory agenda, DOL aims to complete analysis of the comments in August 2024.
H-2 modernization: DHS published a proposal for modernizing H-2 programs on Sept. 20, 2023 intended to reduce inefficiencies, enhance pay protections and address “aspects of the program that may unintentionally result in exploitation or other abuse of persons seeking to come to this country as H-2A and H-2B workers.” Comments were accepted through November 2023 and final action is targeted for November 2024.
Nonimmigrant workers: DHS plans to propose amendments to regulations governing certain nonimmigrant workers including updating the employment authorization rules regarding dependent spouses of certain nonimmigrants; increasing flexibilities for certain nonimmigrant workers and modernizing policies and procedures for employment authorization documents. The targeted publication date is now January 2025.
Immigrant worker reforms: DHS also plans to propose to amend regulations governing employment-based immigrant petitions in the first, second and third preference classifications. According to the regulatory agenda, proposed rule amendments would include updating and modernizing provisions governing extraordinary ability and outstanding professors and researchers; clarifying evidentiary requirements for first preference classifications, second preference national interest waiver classifications and physicians of national and international renown; ensuring the integrity of the I-140 program and correcting errors and omissions. Publication of the proposed rule is now targeted for June 2025.
BAL Analysis: While these regulations would have a significant impact on immigration programs, they are at different stages in the rulemaking process, and policies are still being formulated. Proposed regulations are subject to a public notice-and-comment period, during which members of the public may submit feedback. BAL continues to monitor progress on the regulatory agenda and will provide clients with updates on individual regulations as they move through the rulemaking process.
The passage of the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act (RIA) in 2022 resulted in the most significant changes to the EB-5 investor immigrant visa program since its establishment in 1990. Among the most notable changes implemented through the RIA was the creation of new “set aside” visa categories for EB-5 investors. These set-aside categories allocate a certain amount of the 10,000 EB-5 immigrant visas available each year to investments in certain areas or projects, which include:
20% reserved for qualified immigrants who invest in a rural area;
10% reserved for qualified immigrants who invest in a ‘targeted employment area’ (TEA), which meets the requirements that apply to areas of high unemployment (unemployment rate of at least 150% of the U.S. national average); and
2% reserved for qualified immigrants who invest in infrastructure projects.[1]
Additionally, the RIA allows for the concurrent filing of the investor immigrant visa petition on Form I-526E and adjustment of status (AOS) filing on Form I-485 for those present in the U.S.[2] While certain types of EB-5 investments filed prior to the passage of the RIA remain subject to visa bulletin backlogs, which particularly impact petitioners and dependent family members born in countries with the highest demand for immigrant visas (e.g., mainland China and India), the Visa Bulletin has not yet announced a visa backlog for any of the set aside categories established by the RIA.
With the establishment of the set-aside categories, the availability of EB-5 immigrant visas is now subject to multiple factors, in addition to country of birth, under the Department of State’s Visa Bulletin, which dictates an applicant’s ability to apply for an immigrant visa or concurrent AOS (if in the U.S.) based on per-country limitations released monthly by the Department of State (DOS).[3] As the visa bulletin is based on visas approved visa petitions and the petitioners’ countries of birth (as opposed to petitions filed with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) and currently in process), investors understandably are faced with a level of uncertainty when strategizing the timing of their investments and associated petition filings. This is due to the uncertain nature of the continued availability of immigrant visas, which can retrogress with little notice based on the DOS’ contemporaneous issuance of immigrant visas under the EB-5 program. This post will outline data and strategies available to investors to clarify questions related to potential changes to the visa bulletin that may impact EB-5 immigrant visa availability in the coming months. As the progression of the Visa Bulletin is subject to internal data shared between USCIS and the DOS, as well as the DOS’ internal visa issuance metrics, some level of obscurity and uncertainty should be accounted for when planning for immigrant visa petition filing, but the below is meant to help address and account for these inherent uncertainties.
Background on the Visa Bulletin
In connection with the U.S. government’s policy imperative to encourage a diverse pool of immigrants to the U.S., family- and employment-based immigrant visas are subject to a specific allocation of available visas every federal fiscal year. A total of approximately 140,000 immigrant visas are available every fiscal year for employment-based immigrant visas, including the EB-1, EB-2, EB-3, EB-4, and EB-5 immigrant visa categories. Of the total of 140,000 immigrant visas available annually, approximately 10,000 are allocated to the EB-5 investor visa program, which are also subject to the below per-country visa quotas.
To that end, no one country (based on the applicant’s country of birth) can be allocated more than approximately 7.1% of all available immigrant visas.[4] Importantly, the DOS recently revised its interpretation of the statutory language on the 7.1% per country limit to clarify that it applies in any preference only if a country’s use of visas exceeds 7.1% of all employment-based preferences together.[5] For example, the 7.1% per country limit for Vietnam will only start in the EB-5 category if Vietnam were to reach the 7.1% limit for the overall 140,000 employment-based visas available. In the past, investors born in Vietnam and Taiwan also have been high users of EB-5 visas; however, with this new interpretation by DOS, they will likely never be subject to a per-country limitation for EB-5 again given that these countries generally have never reached 7.1% of the overall 140,000 employment-based immigrant visas.
The above only tells part of the story on immigrant visa allocation. This is because in addition to the total of 140,000 employment-based immigrant visas allocated yearly to all countries, unused visa numbers from prior fiscal years (i.e. immigrant visas that are available to those born in under-subscribed countries, but not utilized) roll over for use by applicants of over-subscribed countries according to priority date and availability within the immigrant visa preference category.[6] Moreover, unused family-based immigrant visas may also be utilized to address excess demand in employment-based categories.[7] While the specific number of unused immigrant visas varies considerably year to year, there tends be some available unused family-based visa numbers from under-subscribed categories each federal fiscal year based on the most recent data made available by USCIS and DOS.[8] Additionally, unused EB-5 numbers from the unreserved ‘general pool’ of EB-5 immigrant visas available yearly (based on worldwide applicant demand), are reallocated to over-subscribed EB-5 categories, including the above-referenced EB-5 set-aside categories created post-RIA implementation.[9]
EB-5 Investor Immigrant Program Data
With the dynamic nature of the immigrant visa allocation process in mind, there is no simple, readily available formula that can help predict the numbers of EB-5 immigrant visas that may be available in a given fiscal year, nor one that can precisely predict how soon retrogression may impact the EB-5 program, particularly in connection with I-526E petitions filed by investors born in traditionally high-demand countries, like China and India. This process is made difficult because USCIS and the Immigrant Investor Program Office (IPO) have not released important statistics to the public that would allow investors to accurately predict how long of a backlog may form in the various set-aside categories. However, we do have some data.
To solve for the lack of government-released data, stakeholders have filed Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests that provide more nuanced data on the government’s current processing volumes. Notably, recent data disclosures made available through FOIA requests found a significant increase in demand for the rural set-aside category, but demand remains “below the needed level to absorb the near-term annual visa supply.” The data released also showed that demand for high unemployment TEA set-aside continued to increase through the end of 2023, which may result in a backlog for that specific set-aside category.[10] As expected, demand remains particularly high for immigrant applicants born in mainland China; the below chart published in connection with the data disclosed pursuant to FOIA provides further insight on the processing volumes:
TOTAL NUMBER OF I-526/I-526E FILED FROM APRIL 1, 2022,TO NOVEMBER 2023, BY TEA CATEGORY AND COUNTRY OF CHARGEABILITY (LATEST STATS AS PER AIIA FOIA DATA)[11]
China
India
Taiwan
Rest of World
Total
Total %
Rural
767
174
18
134
1,093
32%
High unemployment
976
375
209
625
2,185
63%
Infrastructure
0%
Multiple TEA categories
7
3
5
16
0.5%
Not TEA
26
21
6
97
150
4%
Total
1,776
573
233
861
3,444
100%
Total %
52%
17%
7%
25%
100%
While the data above is subject to change and specifically reflects government filings through November 2023, and spanning multiple federal fiscal years (2022-23), it shows that about two times as many high unemployment set-aside I-526E Petitions were filed as compared to rural area set-aside I-526E Petitions. However, in June 2024, USCIS also released their January to March 2024 form data, which revealed that an additional 1,810 I-526E Petitions had been filed with USCIS over that three-month period, leaving 3,672 I-526E Petitions pending as of March 31, 2024.[12]
Importantly, the quarterly USCIS data shows a huge number of new I-526E Petitions were filed during Q2 2024. Half of all I-526E Petitions pending as of the date of this blog were filed just in Q2 of 2024. USCIS has not released any statistics to show the breakdown of I-526E Petitions filed in the high unemployment or rural area set aside categories. Anecdotal evidence from stakeholders and projects seems to show a strong uptick in the demand for rural area projects, and it is possible that many of these new I-526E Petitions were for rural area set-aside visa numbers. More data from USCIS will be required on this point to give investors a more accurate picture on visa wait times in both rural area and high unemployment set-aside projects.
Moreover, the USCIS Q2 2024 data shows that the agency only completed review of 356 I-526E Petitions this fiscal year. The statistics do not break down completions by approvals or denials. Given the small number of case completions during this fiscal year, no visa retrogression has been announced in the Visa Bulletin because an insufficient number of I-526E Petitions have been approved to necessitate announcement of retrogression for any country.
In fact, at a recent conference, the DOS indicated that there is a record amount of EB-5 visas available for this year and predicted again for next year. Specifically, DOS is predicting that there are more than 14,000 unreserved EB-5 visas and more than 8,000 set-aside visas available in FY 2024, and that there will be more than 11,000 unreserved EB-5 visas and more than 6,800 set-aside visas available in FY 2025. Together, that is more than 14,800 set-aside visas over this fiscal year and next, split between rural and high unemployment according to their percentages. This would mean approximately 9,800 rural visas and 4,900 high unemployment EB-5 visas are available over this fiscal year and next, with additional high numbers remaining available in the unreserved EB-5 category. Even assuming that each petitioner also brought two dependent applicants with them to the U.S., the sheer number of EB-5 visas available in these categories over this year and next would provide many immigrant visa numbers for applicants and their dependents in both set-aside categories, and drastic retrogression wait times are not yet predicted.
Additionally, note that the data provided reflects raw numbers of petition filings and does not take into account potential roll overs of additional unused immigrant visas, as noted above. In addition, applicants born in under-subscribed countries, like Vietnam and Taiwan, with robust demand for EB-5 immigrant visas that may qualify for the set-aside category, still have the option to choose to process under the general pool of unreserved EB-5 visa numbers, thereby freeing up additional availability under the reserved high-unemployment and rural TEA set-aside categories for individuals born in mainland China. This selection is typically made at the time that the National Visa Center (NVC) processes the immigrant visa application for applicants based outside of the U.S.
Key Takeaways
There are a record number of EB-5 visas available to applicants in both the high unemployment and rural area set-aside categories in FY 2024 and FY 2025. While stakeholders need more data from USCIS on the breakdowns of pending I-526E Petitions between the high unemployment and rural set-aside categories, there is a record number of visas available and extensive backlogs are not expected to occur like those experienced by pre-RIA I-526 Petitions.
File the I-526E Petition and associated AOS applications concurrently if possible. Although visa numbers remain available in the set-aside categories even for traditionally high-demand countries, the dynamics associated with the DOS Visa bulletin may result in retrogression with little notice. Filing concurrently where eligible can provide multiple benefits in the event of retrogression, including:a. Locking in dependent child’s age under chart A or chart B of the DOS Visa Bulletin, which under the Child Status Protection Act (CSPA) allows for a tolling of age progression while the petition is in process and based on the unavailability of a visa number; and
b. Obtaining short-term U.S. immigration benefits that allow for work (employment authorization document (EAD)) and travel (advance parole (AP)) while the USICS processes the AOS filing.
Individuals born in under-subscribed countries with qualifying investments in rural or high-unemployment TEAs should consider opting for processing under the general unreserved pool where possible. This would allow for use of additional reserved immigrant visas in the set-aside categories by those born in countries with higher demand for EB-5 immigrant visas, such as China and, potentially, India.
Monitor visa bulletin progression and available government data. It will remain important to continue monitoring Visa Bulletin releases and planning for potential retrogression. As noted above, while the set-aside categories created under the RIA remain broadly available for immigrant visas and concurrent AOS processing, conditions may change with little notice as the government processes its backlog of filed EB-5 petitions or if USCIS speeds up its processing of I-526E Petitions.
[8] See, e.g., “Employment-Based Adjustment of Status FAQs,” USCIS, May 20, 2024 (“DOS determined that the FY 2023 employment-based annual limit was 197,091, due to unused family-based visa numbers from FY 2022 being added to the employment-based limit for FY 2023. In addition, 6,396 EB-5 visas carried over from FY 2022 to FY 2023 in the reserved subcategories.”)
On June 18, the executive branch announced one of the most significant executive actions affecting U.S. immigration since establishing the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program in 2012
The family unity action would allow many undocumented spouses of U.S. citizens to obtain green cards in the U.S. without needing to depart the country
The DACA provisions would make it easier for some DACA recipients to qualify for a work visa
On June 18, 2024, the Biden administration announced one of the most significant executive actions promoting family unity and streamlining the process for Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) recipients seeking to transition to work visas using existing legal authority.
Family Unity and Parole in Place for the Undocumented Spouses of U.S. Citizens
The executive actions initiate a process that will allow certain non-citizen spouses of U.S. citizens to apply for their green cards without leaving the U.S. Currently, a U.S. citizen can sponsor their non-citizen, foreign-born spouse for permanent residency by filing an I-130 immigration petition for the individual, regardless of their immigration status. Immigrant visas are available in this category without backlogs, unlike many other categories. However, undocumented spouses who didn’t enter the U.S. legally typically don’t qualify under current law to complete the permanent residency process in the U.S. In these situations, the spouse typically must depart from the U.S. to complete the process at a U.S. embassy or consulate abroad, thereby triggering a 10-year penalty to lawful readmission under immigration law unless waived due to hardship to a qualifying relative. This process is lengthy, uncertain and expensive, discouraging many of these families from pursuing these steps.
To provide relief, the Biden administration proposes to use the humanitarian parole authority of the executive branch to place qualifying individuals in a legal “parole,” which would then allow them to apply for adjustment of status. Approximately half a million spouses and stepchildren of U.S. citizens in “mixed-status” households could benefit from this change, if implemented.
The availability of this program, also known as Parole in Place, for qualifying non-citizen spouses will be formalized through a rule-making process and publication in the Federal Register. However, the subsequent announcement by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) on June 18 included the following specifics for individuals to qualify:
Continuously resided in the U.S. for 10 years since June 17, 2014
Physically present in the U.S. on June 17, 2024
Legally married to a U.S. citizen as of June 17, 2024
Entered the U.S. without admission or parole and do not currently hold any lawful immigrant or nonimmigrant status
Have not been convicted of any disqualifying criminal offense
Do not pose a threat to national security or public safety
Merits a favorable exercise of discretion
This program would also include non-citizen children of these spouses (i.e., stepchildren).
All requests will consider the applicant’s previous immigration history, criminal history, the results of background checks, national security, and public safety vetting, and any other relevant information available to or requested by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.
Employers may stand to benefit from a substantial new group of individuals who will be work authorized and whose statuses could be legalized in the U.S. if this program proceeds.
DACA Recipients and Undocumented College Students
The administration subsequently announced that it is also taking additional steps to facilitate the process for DACA recipients to obtain work visas. DACA was created in 2012 by President Barack Obama as a means for immigrant youth who met certain eligibility requirements to qualify for work authorizations and obtain “deferred action.” While DACA protection has enabled hundreds of thousands of individuals to legally work and live in the U.S., the program has faced considerable uncertainty since 2017, when the Trump administration initially sought to terminate the program but was prevented from doing so in the federal courts.
The program continues to face legal challenges, and additional litigation before the U.S. Supreme Court is very likely. Fundamentally, DACA is not a legal status – the reliance on “deferred action” simply reflects DHS’ decision not to bring immigration removal proceedings against a specific individual. While many DACA recipients and their employers have since sought to transition to a work visa or other legal status that Congress specifically established in the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), the process for doing so is uncertain, expensive and cumbersome. Since DACA recipients either entered without authorization or were out of status when they received DACA protection, they are typically ineligible for a transition to a lawful status within the U.S.
Instead, they are required under immigration law to “consular process” outside the U.S. and obtain a work visa at a U.S. consulate. The individual’s departure from the U.S. could trigger removal bars (similar to those described above), requiring the individual to obtain a temporary waiver of inadmissibility from the government. These waivers, known as “d3 waivers” based on the section of the INA to which they relate, can take months to obtain and the outcome of such a waiver is not certain. These cumulative issues have chilled the interest of many employers and DACA recipients in pursuing these waivers.
In the coming weeks, the administration is expected to announce additional steps to streamline the availability of d3 waivers. The U.S. Department of State will announce changes to its process for granting such waivers to DACA recipients through updates to the Foreign Affairs Manual, and DHS has indicated that it will adopt the State Department’s policy changes. These steps, if implemented, are very good news for many employers and the DACA recipients that they employ by providing a more efficient, robust and reliable process for transitioning DACA recipients to a more stable and lawful status in the U.S.
Coalition for the American Dream published the report days ahead of the 12th anniversary of the DACA program on June 15.
Current DACA recipients number more than 500,000. The report finds that future long-term economic losses and costs could approach $1 trillion over the lifetimes of DACA recipients.
Other economic and workforce impacts include:
As many as 168,000 U.S. jobs in DACA-owned businesses could be lost.
U.S. workforce losses could include 37,000 healthcare workers, 17,000 STEM professionals and 17,000 educators.
Lost business training and recruitment costs for current DACA employees could reach $8 billion.
Additional Information: The report’s demographic and economic estimates and business impacts are based in part on data collected in the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2022 American Community Survey, the March 2022-2023-2024 Current Population Surveys and data from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.
Coalition for the American Dream is an organization of more than 100 businesses, trade associations and other groups representing every major sector of the U.S. economy and more than half of American private sector workers. Its mission is to seek the passage of bipartisan legislation that gives Dreamers a permanent solution.
BAL Analysis: The report notes if DACA ended and work authorizations were denied renewal, 440,000 workers would be forced from the U.S. workforce over a two-year period, with the most acute impact on health, education and STEM occupations. The business community continues to show strong support for DACA and the crucial role Dreamers play in the U.S. economy. Given the uncertain environment, DACA recipients who qualify for a renewal are urged to apply for one as soon as they can.
As summer and baseball season are now in full swing, so is the H-1B filing season. The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) completed its initial round of selections on April 1, prompting immigration practitioners and employers to get filings across the home plate by June 30. However, many potential employees are stuck in the dugout, so to speak, unable to get in the game, as they were not selected in the H-1B lottery.
The H-1B visa category provides temporary work authorization to individuals employed in a role involving a specialty occupation. Most commonly known for its restrictive numerical limitations, the H-1B visa category caps the number of new visas issued each year at 65,000, with an additional 20,000 available to graduates of U.S. master’s degree programs. While 85,000 H-1B visa holders would exceed more than twice the occupancy of the Atlanta Braves’ Truist Park, it has become increasingly difficult to obtain an H-1B visa under the current lottery system due to a high volume of submissions, the increased likelihood of fraud, and the number of submissions designed to beat the system.
While the H-1B remains a first choice among U.S. employers for the temporary employment of foreign nationals, many wonder whether it continues to be a game worth playing. Such thoughts have prompted employers to turn to other non-immigrant visa lineups, such as the H-1B1, E-3, TN, and O-1:
H-1B1, Specialty Occupation Workers from Chile or Singapore
The H-1B1 visa is a subcategory of the H-1B category, providing work authorization options to specialty occupation workers from Chile and Singapore. Current laws limit the annual number of qualifying foreign workers eligible to obtain an H-1B1 visa to 6,800, allocating 1,400 for nationals of Chile and 5,400 for those of Singapore.
The greatest advantage of this subclassification is the ability to forego the H-1B visa lottery. Further, the H-1B1 visa does not have a six-year limit. The period of employment is one year, with subsequent extensions available in one-year increments.
E-3, Specialty Occupation Workers From Australia
Applying only to nationals of Australia, the E-3 nonimmigrant visa classification provides another option for specialty occupation workers. Similar to the H-1B1, participation in the annual H-1B lottery is not a prerequisite to admission in E-3 status.
TN, Temporary Workers From Mexico and Canada
Yet another alternative to the H-1B visa is the TN visa, designated for select professionals who are citizens of Canada and Mexico. The U.S. Mexico-Canada Agreement, formerly the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), provides special economic and trade relationships for the U.S., Canada and Mexico. This classification permits qualified Canadian and Mexican citizens to work temporarily in the U.S. at a professional level. Professions on the list include accountants, engineers, lawyers, pharmacists, scientists and teachers.
Employers focused on expediency surely are interested in this nonimmigrant visa category. Not only does the TN visa forego the H-1B lottery, but it also can circumvent the Labor Condition Application requirement, which is a Department of Labor process requiring approximately seven days.
O-1, Individuals of Extraordinary Ability
The O-1 nonimmigrant visa is for the individual who possesses extraordinary ability in the sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics, or who has a demonstrated record of extraordinary achievement in the motion picture or television industry and received recognition nationally or internationally for such achievements. Those eligible for O-1A classification are individuals with an extraordinary ability in the sciences, education, business, or athletics (not including the arts, motion pictures or television industry).
The O-1B visa category is intended for individuals with an extraordinary ability in the arts or extraordinary achievement in motion picture or television industry.
Of particular importance, one of the top benefits of an O-1 visa in comparison to an H-1B is the lack of annual limits on the number of O-1 visas issued. Moreover, as numerical caps and a lottery process do not restrict the O-1 visa, the application period is not limited to a specific filing window. Further, unlike some nonimmigrant visa categories, O-1 filings are not restricted by an annual filing period, and the overall cost of the O-1 process can be significantly less.
The O-1 visa category also boasts employer flexibility as the beneficiary does not have to be directly employed by the entity for which they will work, but could work for a U.S. agent. The O-1 also provides significant relief with respect to the potential length of the visa, as this nonimmigrant visa classification offers unlimited one-year extensions of the initial three-year period.
As many potential H-1B employees have not received the call-up, these other nonimmigrant visa categories present viable alternatives.
Tieranny L. Cutler, independent contract attorney, co-authored this article.
